Spanning words

What was wrong with the old Flickr map?

Maybe it’s just me, but I think the continent spanning words (tags) on the new Flickr map are a step backwards regarding usability, compared to the really nicely done photo-dots-generalization the previous version of the map had. The only interactivity on the new map is clicking tags, right? Or did I miss something? I really preferred the old version where I could zoom down to photo-dots and browse through photos directly on the location.

Well, it must be my dot-fetish, but on the new user maps the generalized dots are gone too. Now you see the most recent (or interesting) photographs placed on the map, which is just another exploring approach. If you scroll through the pictures on the bar, the map changes too, unfortunately not vice versa. When you pan the map, the photos aren’t updated in the bar. Would be something nice to have too.

Whereas the new Places feature is awesome. One page per place, containing excellently chosen photographs, active groups and people on that location. Very well done. Even though I wish I could navigate to other places more easily. With some interactivity on the small map or links to popular neighboring places for instance. Currently I have to go up and down in regional hierarchy or use the location search.

Vienna on Flickr Places

Even Flickr’s “Safe Search” works in Places. Although there are some properly tagged photos (and a whole lot more!) for an unluckily named Austrian village on Flickr, it remains for some reasons banned in Places…

Possibly related posts

  • Tags on maps can create interesting pictures. The strange maps blog provides some good examples I think.

    But the tagged world map on Flickr doesn't really make sense. The tags seem randomly chosen and placed (e.g. "themeetingplace" in the middle of the Atlantic ocean).
  • I missed this change over, but I completely agree. The "Tagmap" is almost entirely useless. Why would I find it useful to see (as I did) the two tags covering South America as "hugsandkisses" and a phrase in Russian.

    The concept is interesting. Denoting place by feeling, or other representation than toponym. However Flickr is a *photo* tool, and I find the various, semi-random tags chosen to show up (e.g. "ubcle"?) on the map not useful in exploring the world.

    And I think you mentioned this, but there isn't any zoom functionality.

    Here's to hoping they bring back the dots! Or at least something more usable and pertinent.
blog comments powered by Disqus